R t
 
$1.00 INCL GST
     
     

Play Date


Levi Slocombe, 2, and his mom Lisa play with a chick at the petting zoo at The Station Cultural Centre during the Olde Town Fair on Saturday afternoon in downtown Okotoks. photo by John Barlow

Judge re-routes school bus issue

By Bruce Campbell
Staff Reporter

A court of Queen’s Bench judge has ruled Foothills School Division did not follow its own policies of public consultation when it eliminated in June of 2006 four bus routes carrying 284 students.
“The duty of fairness owed by the board was breached when the board made the decision of June 7, 2006, without consultation as promised in the board meeting of June 1, 2005. For this reason, the decision is quashed,” Judge Dennis G. Hart, wrote in his conclusion of his ruling, which was released Wednesday afternoon.
Applicants for the judicial review said Hart’s decision is a “David vs. Goliath” victory and showed that the board does not follow its own policies in regards to public consultation.
“The board was arguing that despite a policy framework and despite the fact their chairman made a promise, we aren’t bound by those promises,” said Jay Lyons, a spokesman for 10 parents who sought a court injunction against the board cutting the bus routes. You can’t have nice policy language that suggests consultation and then say, despite that we don’t have to do that... You can’t have it both ways.”
Lyons stressed the main issue for the legal process was concerns about the division’s proper consultation with the public it wasn’t a busing issue.
The board eliminated a grandfathering clause, which allowed school-of-choice students those receiving busing to a Foothills school outside his or her geographic boundary at its June 7, 2006 meeting.
The June 7 decision eliminated four bus routes and affected 284 students. The decision meant those students who attend out-of-boundary schools would have to meet a bus within that school’s boundary. They would also be charged a transportation fee.
The Foothills School Division did extensive open houses in the late 1990s and early 2000s when similar transportation issues were discussed.
Hart ruled that Foothills chairman Jerry Muelaner promised public consultation during a June 1, 2005 meeting. The judge quoted the board’s minutes from that meeting in his decision: “Chair Muelaner concluded the conversation by describing what the board and administration did about five years ago with visiting all school councils to discuss the transportation issues and the fees that are implemented and that the board would like to do this again.”
Hart also stated he did not believe the board could differentiate between the June 1, 2005 promise being one made solely by Muelaner and not by the board, because none of the other trustees spoke against Muelaner’s proposal.
Hart stated proper public consultation was not given between June 1,2005 and the board’s final decision on June 7, 2006.
Lyons added while he does not expect the buses to be back up and running this week, he suggests that if the division had a contingency plan in the event they lost the ruling, that would have been the case.
Drew Chipman, Foothills School Division secretary-treasurer, said the board and the division were surprised by Hart’s decision.
“Our lawyer still believes the board acted appropriately,î Chipman said on Thursday.
He added the four bus routes wouldn't be restarted immediately.
ìWe may decide to do something in the not-too-distant future,î Chipman said. ìBased on the ruling, we have to make decisions quick.î
He said the grandfathering issue hit virtually all parts of the division. He said he believes the decision only applies to those students affected by the decision of June 7, 2006.
He said the board made its decision for two reasons ñ financial and the interest of good practice.
ìIn order to run an efficient transportation system that is sustainable over time, the board has to make sure it is operating in a responsible manner,î Chipman said. ìTo run buses to different schools and communities doesnít make sense in the long term.î
He said the division saved approximately $240,000 by the elimination of the clause and altering other routes. Chipman estimates a reduction of 1,100 kilometres a day in busing due to the June 7, 2006 decision. He stressed the board did not contravene any provincial transportation guidelines when it eliminated the grandfathering clause.
ìIt was a procedural issue, according to the ruling,î Chipman said.
Muelaner said it would be premature to talk about Hartís decision. He said the divisionís legal advisors are looking over the decision.
He expects the division will make an announcement concerning the ruling at its Sept. 5 public meeting.


Staff shortages taking toll on business

Now that many young workers have headed back to school, some employers in Okotoks and the surrounding area are finding it difficult to maintain service levels.
With summer, often businesses find it easier to hire students looking to make some extra cash over the holiday. But as fall sets in those same workers either cut back the amount of hours they can work or quit entirely to focus on education.
The MacDonald’s restaurant in Okotoks is one such business feeling the labour crunch of back to school time. Anne-Marie Gloutnez, swing manager of the Okotoks MacDonald’s, said the restaurant employs roughly 50 people, with about 35 of those being high school students. She said with students heading off to school they have been forced to minimize their operation due to labour shortages.
“Sometimes we have to close the drive-through or the lobby earlier because we are so short staffed,” Gloutnez said.
Gloutnez said during this time of year, and even through the summer, McDonald’s consistently tries to hire more staff, but she admits that it can be difficult because not everyone wants to work at a fast food restaurant. She said it has been so difficult to retain employees that the owner went to Mexico to recruit staff.
By offering incentives such as a $10 per hour starting wage, health insurance and scholarship opportunities, Gloutnez said they are doing all they can to attain and retain staff members.
“We are already short staffed so it sure affects our labour shift. It’s really hard for us,” Gloutnez said.
According to Bill Hankins, first assistant manager of Okotoks Safeway, back to school time is hard for them as well. Although the grocery store hires and retains many senior personnel, there are also a number of students who can’t continue working the same amount of hours they did in the summer, often limiting their schedules to weekends and evenings.
“General clerks I probably have six who have just headed back to school,” Hankins said. “So now in summer time they were available during the day, now I don’t have people available during the day. That’s going to cause us some shortages, it’s a tough time.”
Like McDonald’s, Hankins said Safeway tries to offer a competitive starting wage at $10 per hour. However, Hankins said when it comes to the individual store in Okotoks, there is only so much they can do to attract potential employees.
“Our hands are tied, it’s what the company does,” Hankins said. “There’s nothing we can do here store specific.”
Although Okotoks’ VHQ and Movie Gallery has had trouble maintaining staff, the situation can’t be entirely blamed on students heading back to school, according to Adeline Moore, manager of the two video rental stores. She said the company has a policy to only hire individuals 18 or older. She added the two stores only have two or three students working for them as a result of their policy, however, it’s been retaining store managers that has been a challenge.
“(At the Movie Gallery) it’s been fairly good for the past nine months, we’ve had the same staff,” Moore said. “Here (at VHQ) it seems to be a revolving door. They come and they go, they come and they go, so its always hire, hire, hire. But we seem to find the people, because they do seem to want to work for us.”
In seasonal occupations, dealing with students going back to school is a fact of life, according to Brock Balog, Highwood Golf and Country Club head pro. Balog said his department has prepared for the staff shortfall by hiring more seniors to cover the loss of students. But as fall arrives, Balog said the need for all the staff is reduced due to slower grass growing times, shorter daylight hours and cooler weather.
“You still need staff, but it definitely adjusts itself to go to skeleton (staff) to begin with,” Balog said. “It’s just being prepared for that stuff. If you’ve hired all students, then shame on you, you should know they’re eventually going to go back.”
Balog said back to school time can put stress on the club, however, with good incentives such as free golf and pro shop discounts, he knows the workers will return in the spring.
Normally the club hires only about eight youths between the ages of 14 to 16 in the back shop position. To accommodate those teens looking to have freedom on weekends, Balog said they hired 20 this season so the hours are more flexible. As well, Balog said they offer rewards to those who stay the whole season with a bonus and a healthy working atmosphere.
“It’s great having the students and it’s a great summer job to hang out at the golf course,” Balog said.
“It’s not like it’s a stressful job, everybody’s there to have fun and play golf. What you’re basically doing is preparing yourself so that they have enough fun and experience that they want to come back next year,” Balog said.
For employers looking for ways to attract and maintain workers, the Calgary Regional Partnership is offering a free one-day Employee Retention Workshop. The workshop will be held in Okotoks on Sept. 18 at the Rotary Room at the Foothills Centennial Centre from 7:30 a.m. to 10 a.m.


In this issue...

 

Special recognition

Local earns national award for
volunteer work
• See News

Rockin’ Good Time


Sell-out crowds enjoy
Okotoks rodeo
• See Sports



News Stories

Editorial

Sports Archives



Published Wednesdays at Okotoks, Alberta, Canada. Serving the communities of Okotoks, Aldersyde, Black Diamond, DeWinton, Longview, Millarville, Priddis, Turner Valley, Bragg Creek, and the rural ratepayers of the M.D. of Foothills. And now the World. Established August 3, 1976.